Learn

What happens when a new policy replaces an old one?

By Mickie Byrd · updated 2026-10-18

When a new policy replaces an old one, the old one usually ends or shrinks. The new one starts fresh. That can bring a lower price or a better fit. It also restarts some things, and it can cost money. Texas adds steps so you can see what the old policy holds first. You also get 30 days to return the new one.

This is called a replacement. It counts when the old policy is ended, cashed in, or cut back. It also counts when money from the old policy pays for the new one. That money might be its cash value, or a loan against it. The same rules cover annuities, which are contracts that pay income.

People replace a policy for real reasons. A new one may cost less, or fit life today better. Some people combine several small policies into one. The steps below let the two policies be compared side by side.

Some things start over. With a different company, the 2-year look back at your application answers begins again. So does the suicide clause. That part of a policy limits what it pays for a death by suicide in the first years. The policy states how long it lasts. With the same company, or one tied to it, the time already passed usually counts.

The price can change too. A new policy is priced for your age today, and the health questions are asked again. Ending an old policy early may bring a surrender charge, a fee for ending it early. A new annuity can start a new surrender charge period. Cashing out a policy can also raise a tax question, which a tax professional can answer.

Texas adds a few steps. The agent is the licensed person who takes your application. When you apply, you and the agent sign a statement saying whether you have a policy or annuity now. If you do, the agent reads you a state-approved notice about replacing a policy. You can choose to read it alone instead. You both sign it, and you keep a copy.

Next, the new company tells the old company within 5 business days. The old company then sends you a letter about your right to see what your policy holds. If you ask, it sends that within 5 business days. It shows what the old policy is worth and pays today. These steps are set out in the Texas Insurance Code.

You have 30 days after delivery to return the new policy. You get back all you paid, with nothing kept for fees. Kinds that rise and fall with investments refund their value that day, plus fees. Sending the new policy back does not bring back an old policy that was already cashed in.

A few kinds of change fall outside these steps, such as most coverage through work. The old company and the new one can each answer questions about their own policy. Questions about the Texas rules can go to the Texas Department of Insurance.

Common questions

What counts as replacing a policy?
Getting a new policy or annuity that ends, cashes in, or cuts back one you have. Using an old policy's value to pay for a new one counts too.
How long do I have to return the new policy?
30 days after delivery. You get back all you paid, with nothing kept for fees. Kinds that rise and fall with investments refund their value that day, plus fees.
Does the 2-year look back start over?
With a different company, yes, and so does the suicide clause. With the same company or one tied to it, the time already passed usually counts. That credit goes up to the old policy's amount, and the new policy states it.
Can I find out what my old policy is worth?
Yes. The old company sends you a letter about your right to that information. When you ask, it has 5 business days to send it.